Monday, February 10, 2014

The Strike Force Approach to Combatting Health Care Fraud

Bridget M. Rohde02/10/2014

The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General (HHS-OIG) and other federal and state agencies are aggressively prosecuting health care fraud and related offenses through a strike force approach that has its roots in DOJ's historic efforts to combat traditional organized crime (or "La Cosa Nostra"). As DOJ has advised in recent press releases, this approach has been highly impactful in the health care space:
Since its inception in March 2007, the Medicare Fraud Strike Force, now operating in nine cities across the country, has charged more than 1,700 defendants who collectively have billed the Medicare program for more than $5.5 billion. In addition, HHS's Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services, working in conjunction with HHS-OIG, is taking steps to increase accountability and decrease the presence of fraudulent providers. 1
Below, we look at the historic organized crime strike force program, the evolution of the Medicare Fraud Strike Force (MFSF) and MFSF's current approach and seemingly ever-increasing productivity.
Historic Organized Crime Strike Forces
In the 1960s, to address the long-ignored presence of organized crime and its numerous rackets, DOJ developed an organized crime strike force program in which teams of prosecutors in cities across the country focused on the families of La Cosa Nostra operating in their local geographic jurisdictions. These prosecutors worked in partnership with investigators from a variety of federal agencies, and, sometimes local law enforcement as well. Investigations were long-term efforts, as the teams of prosecutors and agents gathered intelligence through confidential sources, electronic surveillance and other investigative techniques,and methodically built broad, deep and impactful cases.
Early on, DOJ touted the success of its organized crime strike forces in much the same way as it now does the success of MFSF: "Individuals indicted during 1968 as a result of strike force strategy numbered 71 in Brooklyn, 67 in Detroit, 34 in Buffalo, 12 in Chicago and 5 in Philadelphia." 2
At the time of the merger of the strike forces with local U.S. Attorneys Offices in 1990, there were 14 strike forces across the country, located in Brooklyn, Buffalo, Chicago, Cleveland, Detroit, Kansas City, Las Vegas, Los Angeles, Miami, New Orleans and San Francisco. 3
The success of the organized crime strike force approach (and continuing efforts of the U.S. Attorneys' Offices) was incontrovertible. Waves of prosecutions relentlessly taking down the successive hierarchies of the five New York City-based families of La Cosa Nostra is one of the more memorable local examples. While perhaps surprising at first blush, the use of a variation on this approach to combat white-collar crime, including health care fraud, now seems a logical, even inevitable, law enforcement strategy.
The Birth and Evolution of the MFSM
MFSF was initiated in March 2007, in what came to be Phase One, in the Southern District of Florida (Miami). A year later, in March 2008, Phase Two was kicked off in the Central District of California (Los Angeles). As part of the Health Care Fraud Prevention and Enforcement Action Team (HEAT) initiative, a joint effort by DOJ and HHS, in 2009, MFSF expanded to Detroit, Houston, Brooklyn, Tampa and Baton Rouge. In 2011, the program expanded to the total of nine cities it is today, by adding Dallas and Chicago.
Phase One of MFSF was announced in connection with a May 2007 takedown in the Southern District in Florida involving the indictment of organizations and individuals in connection with allegedly conspiring to defraud the Medicare program, making false claims and violating the anti-kickback statute. Thirty-eight individuals were arrested. Collectively, approximately $142 million was allegedly billed in Medicare. MFSF was then described as "a multi-agency team of federal, state and local investigators designed specifically to combat Medicare fraud through the use of real-time analysis of Medicare billing data," focusing on schemes involving infusion therapy and durable medical equipment (DMEs). 4
MFSF became much more. There was the noted expansion to nine cities. In addition to takedowns of discreet cases in particular cities, in late 2009, MFSF began conducting periodic nationwide takedowns, with individuals being arrested in a number of cities simultaneously in connection with healthcare-related offenses. A July 2010 nationwide takedown appears to be the largest such takedown to date, with the arrest of 94 individuals across the country for allegedly participating in schemes to submit approximately $251 million in Medicare claims. 5
Over the years that MFSF has been in existence, it has utilized other hallmarks of the strike force approach to fighting organized crime besides multi-agency cooperation and sprawling takedowns, including employing electronic surveillance techniques, expanding the range of crimes charged, obtaining (and issuing press releases regarding) long prison sentences imposed on individuals, and even having "most wanted" healthcare fugitives. Penalties of fines, forfeiture and restitution have been utilized to recoup public monies and disincentivize fraudsters.
The Current Look of MFSF Cases
A review of MFSF prosecutions in 2013 provides numerous insights into the increasingly broad scope and continuing effectiveness of the strike force approach to combatting healthcare fraud:
Many Venues of Prosecution. DOJ and its partners brought cases across the country, including in California, Florida, Illinois, Louisiana, Michigan, New York, Pennsylvania, Texas and Utah. Certain federal districts had a particularly high concentration of MFSF cases, including the Southern District of Florida, Eastern District of Michigan and Central District of California.
Variety of Health Care Providers Targeted. Cases targeted executives of a health maintenance organization; the owner/operator of an oncology center; the medical director of a hospice; the owner and program coordinator of an adult day care center; owners and others associated with partial hospitalization programs (PHPs); owners and others associated with home health care agencies; owners and others associated with DMEs; owners of ambulance services; and doctors, registered nurses and other medical professionals.
Types of Crimes Charged. Charges included healthcare fraud for submitting false and fraudulent claims to Medicare, violations of the anti-kickback statute, and, in some recent cases, money laundering.
Wide-ranging penalties. Sentences included the imposition of lengthy prison terms; fines, restitution, and forfeiture; exclusions from Medicare, Medicaid and other federal and state health programs; and compliance requirements.
Some specific matters further illustrate the scope of MFSF's efforts and its results.
1. May 2013 Nationwide Takedown. As noted above, MFSF's sixth nationwide takedown took place in May 2013. DOJ and HHS announced arrests in eight cities of 89 individuals, including health care company owners, doctors, nurses and other licensed medical professionals, for allegedly participating in Medicare fraud schemes involving approximately $223 million in billings. Schemes involved billings for home health care, mental health services, psychotherapy, occupational and physical therapy, and pharmacy fraud, as well as infusion therapy and DMEs. Charges included conspiracy to commit health care fraud, violations of the anti-kickback statute and money laundering. 6
2. Multi-million Medicare Fraud Scheme involving Brooklyn Clinic. In addition to the nationwide takedown, MFSF also brought or continued to prosecute individual cases that further illustrate the strike force approach and its results. One illuminating local example is a case charging a $77 million Medicare fraud scheme involving a Brooklyn, New York clinic. The owner and employees of the clinic allegedly paid kickbacks to Medicare beneficiaries and used the beneficiaries' names to bill Medicare for services that were medically unnecessary or never provided. The kickbacks were allegedly paid so that beneficiaries would keep quiet about services that were not provided or would acquiesce to treatment that was unnecessary. A network of money launderers was allegedly used to generate the cash needed for the kickbacks. 7
As of late last year, 13 individuals had been convicted in connection with the multi-million scheme. The owner of the clinic, who pled guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit money laundering, was sentenced to 15 years in prison and ordered to pay approximately $51 million in restitution and $36 million in forfeiture. Another participant—an individual described as a "no-show" doctor who allegedly let the clinic use his Medicare billing number and rarely visited the clinic except to pick up his check—was sentenced to more than 12 years in prison, ordered to pay over $50 million in restitution and another half million in forfeiture and was excluded from Medicare, Medicaid and federal health programs; additionally, New York state revoked his medical license. An individual who "impersonated" the doctor—signing medical charts and prescriptions in the doctor's name and performing medical procedures on patients even though he was not a doctor—was sentenced to eight years in prison, as well as restitution, forfeiture and program exclusions. Among those awaiting sentencing is an individual who pled guilty to laundering the proceeds of the health care fraud through a number of shell companies and bank accounts. 8
In addition to the dollar amount of the fraud scheme,the inclusion of money laundering charges and the variety and size of penalties, this case is notable because the government utilized investigative techniques historically used to investigate organized crime and, in more recent years, investigate insider trading. Specifically, the government stated in press releases regarding this case that it employed a court-authorized audio/video device concealed in a room at the clinic where conspirators gave cash to Medicare beneficiaries. Fitting in with the organized crime analogy, the room included "a Soviet-era poster of a woman with a finger to her lips and the words 'Don't Gossip' in Russian." 9
Effect of Strike Force Approach
As indicated above, in 2009, DOJ and HHS formed the Health Care Fraud Prevention and Enforcement Action Team, or HEAT, which includes the strike force efforts but is more expansive. For one, HEAT is also responsible for many significant civil enforcement actions resulting in multi-million dollar settlements over the last few years. These civil enforcement actions are developed and prosecuted using what can fairly be referred to as a modified strike force approach. DOJ and HHS, often in conjunction with one or more federal or state partner, work cooperatively to investigate and bring expansive cases against pharmaceutical or medical device companies charging violations of the False Claims Act, Food Drug and Cosmetics Act, the anti-kickback statute or other laws and regulations. Commonly, based on a qui tam complaint, an investigation will target specified conduct like off-label marketing of pharmaceuticals or introduction of adulterated drugs into commerce, seek monetary penalties and require remediation of the violations and adherence to a compliance protocol going forward.
A case in point from 2013 involved Johnson & Johnson. On Nov. 4, 2013, DOJ announced a deal requiring Johnson & Johnson and three of its subsidiaries to pay more than $2.2 billion to resolve criminal exposure and civil liability arising from marketing prescription drugs for uses not approved as safe and effective by the Food & Drug Administration (FDA), as well as for paying kickbacks to doctors and the country's largest long-term care pharmacy provider for prescribing and promoting these drugs. 10
To address its criminal exposure, on November 7, Johnson & Johnson subsidiary Janssen Pharmaceuticals Incorporated pled guilty to a misdemeanor charge of misbranding, in violation of the FDCA, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. Specifically, Janssen was alleged to have introduced the drug Risperdal into the market for unapproved uses from March 2002 through December 2003, namely treating behaviors of elderly, non-schizophrenic patients suffering from dementia, when it had been approved only for the treatment of schizophrenia; the criminal fines and forfeiture component of the criminal resolution is $400 million. 11
Civil lawsuits similarly claimed that Johnson & Johnson and Janssen promoted Risperdal to doctors and nursing homes for unapproved uses in the elderly, children and mental disabled. A complaint in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania specifically alleged that the FDA repeatedly advised Janssen that marketing Risperdal as safe and effective for the elderly would be misleading. It also alleged that Janssen downplayed health risks to the elderly posed by Risperdal and improperly promoted its use in children. Speaker fees were allegedly paid to doctors to encourage them to write prescriptions. In addition, Johnson & Johnson and Janssen allegedly engaged in off-label promotion of a newer anti-psychotic drug, Invega. 12
Johnson & Johnson and Janssen agreed to pay over $1.2 billion to resolve civil liability under the False Claims Act in relation to Risperdal and Invega. In addition, Johnson & Johnson agreed to pay another $149 million in connection with the alleged kickbacks that were allegedly paid to the large long-term care pharmacy. 13
An additional component of the resolution was a five-year Corporate Integrity Agreement, described as requiring major changes to the way Johnson & Johnson's pharmaceutical subsidiaries do business. Annual compliance certifications are required by certain management employees and board members. As the government stated,"[t]his agreement is designed to increase accountability and transparency and prevent future fraud and abuse." 14
A telling remark by U.S. Attorney General Holder Eric Holder, who delivered remarks at the press conference on this resolution, is that pharmacists, who were supposed to be "gatekeepers" providing independent review of patient medications, instead recommended the drugs for unapproved uses at the companies' request. 15
Conclusion
In 2014, MFSF is in full flower. There is every reason to expect the strike force approach to be utilized for the foreseeable future, unless and until health care fraud significantly diminishes as a public concern. The specific cases arising from MSFS' efforts in 2013 can help drive risk assessments and fine-tuning of compliance programs to avoid repeating the expensive mistakes made by some in the health care industry in the past. The resolutions of these cases serve as a reminder of the need to prioritize compliance.
Bridget M. Rohde, a member of Mintz Levin in New York, is a former chief of the Criminal Division of the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of New York.

Sunday, February 9, 2014

Optometrist sentenced to 33 months in federal prison for Medicare fraud

An Augusta-based optometrist who expanded a single office into a string of offices on both sides of the Savannah River will serve 33 months in prison for Med­icare fraud.
At the end of an all-day sentencing hearing in U.S. District Court on Thursday, Judge J. Randal Hall told Dr. Jeffrey Sponseller that what troubled him most about the hours of testimony was the defense’s apparent theme that bad employees and sloppy record-keeping were to blame.
“When it comes to health care fraud, a lot of people look at these types of cases and say, ‘Well, it’s just the government,’ ” Hall said. But it’s a crime against all taxpayers who must pay for care of the elderly and disabled covered by Medicare, Hall said.
Sponseller, 48, pleaded guilty in February to filing false claims. On Thursday, he admitted he defrauded Medicare and other government health care programs from January 2008 through 2010.
The investigation centered on Sponseller’s billing for Eye Care One services for nursing home patients in Georgia.
Because of the amount of fraud – which was the subject of Thursday’s hearing – Sponseller faced a sentencing range of 33 to 37 months in prison.
Defense attorney Pete Theo­­docion challenged the government’s calculations that Sponseller defrauded Med­i­care of more than $441,000.
The Medicare billing code Sponseller used most often was for the most comprehensive exam possible that would be needed for a new and medically complex case, according to testimony from Jean Stone, the director of the Northeast Integrity Field Operations of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
When Stone studied case files collected from Spon­sel­ler’s office and nursing homes, the documentation was completely inadequate for such billing. In fact, it was so minimal that it wouldn’t qualify for any kind of Medi­care payment, she said.
Kim Reinken, an investigator with the U.S. attorney’s office, analyzed Sponseller’s billings and case files, finding that on a single day in July 2009, he billed Medicare for the 45-minute comprehensive exam on 177 patients.
She also found that Sponseller was the highest recipient of Medicare payments for that billing procedure in the nation. The second-highest recipient billed for less than half of what Sponseller did.
FBI Special Agent Paul Ku­bala testified that at one nursing home, Sponseller billed for comprehensive exams of 59 patients in about three hours. Four of those patients told the nursing home director that they never saw Sponseller, and another patient didn’t have eyes.
An investigator with the Of­fice of Inspector General of Health and Human Services, David Graupner, testified that in 2007, Sponseller was audited and placed in specialized tutoring for Medi­care billing because of questionable billing practices.
In 2009 and 2010, one of the billing codes Sponseller used was for a specialized photograph. No such photographs were found in any of his patient records, Graupner testified.
Assistant U.S. Attorney David Stewart argued that the nearly half-million dollars in restitution was a reasonable request. The government wasn’t seeking repayment of more than $1 million paid to Sponseller over the two-year period in question.
In the end, the judge sided with the prosecution. A telling factor for Hall was that while Sponseller was billing for a procedure required for a difficult diagnosis or a very ill patient, rarely did he seek payment for follow-up treatment of these patients.

Speech therapist stole thousands from Medicaid, authorities say

A licensed speech therapist from Orange County was arrested Friday after she was accused of committing Medicaid fraud and stealing several thousand dollars.
Tiffany Campbell filed false records so she could collect payment for services she never completed last summer, a statement from the Attorney General Pam Bondi's office said.
"Campbell's employer billed Medicaid for more than $8,000 in speech therapy services never rendered based on Campbell's fraudulent logs," the statement said.
Campbell was supposed to be helping young children between 3 and 13 years old. But according the parents of Campbell's patients, the speech therapist regularly canceled appointments and refused to work over the summer.
If convicted, Campbell could face up to five years in prison or up to $10,000 in fines.


Thursday, February 6, 2014

Hospital administrator and businessmen sentenced to prison for submitting fraudulent cost reports to Medicare

MONROE, La. (AP) — A former Madison Parish Hospital administrator and two of its vendors have been sentenced for health care fraud.
U.S. Attorney Stephanie A. Finley said Tuesday that U.S. District Judge Robert G. James sentenced Charles W. Alford, 71, of Newellton, to 37 months in prison and ordered him to pay $1.3 million in restitution.
James also sentenced Barney W.I. Hughes IV, 45, of Keller, Texas, to a year in prison and ordered him to pay $566,874 restitution and Henry R. Ham, 65, of West Monroe, to 14 months in prison and $817,000 in restitution.
According to evidence presented at Monday's guilty plea, Alford was hospital administrator for Madison Parish Hospital in Tallulah; Hughes served as owner of Tech Solutions of Keller, Texas; and Ham, was owner of Insurance World in Monroe.
Both Hughes and Ham paid Alford a combined total of more than $1.3 million in kickbacks for his approval and continuation of their business agreements.
Madison Parish Hospital leased equipment and personnel from Tech Solutions to operate the hospital's nuclear medicine and ultrasound departments.
At no time did Alford or Hughes disclose to the hospital's board or Medicare that they had an exclusive agreement. From October 2006 to June 2012, the hospital paid Hughes' company $2,029,504, and Hughes paid Alford $566,874 of that total. They submitted fraudulent cost reports to Medicare at least six times from December 2006 to 2011.
Madison Parish Hospital purchased a majority of its health insurance and life insurance products from Ham. Alford and Ham negotiated and set the insurance policy rates and Alford approved Ham's billings as well as the hospital's payments to Ham.
From 2007 through April 2012, the hospital paid Ham $4,979,487, and Ham paid Alford $817,000 of that total. They submitted fraudulent cost reports to Medicare at least five times from December 2007 to 2011.


Husband, wife and business associate charged with health care fraud

William Owuama, 55, Marla Owuama, 46, and Florida Holiday Island, 64, all of Houston, have been charged in an eight-count indictment alleging conspiracy to commit health care fraud, health care fraud and conspiracy to violate the federal anti-kickback statute, announced United States Attorney Kenneth Magidson.


The sealed indictment, returned Jan. 22, was unsealed this afternoon as all three defendants made their initial appearance before U.S. Magistrate Judge Frances Stacy at 2 p.m. At the hearing, Judge Stacy permitted Marla Owuama and Island be released upon posting bond. Upon surrendering his passport, William Owuama is also expected to be released upon posting bond.

The indictment alleges William Owuama was the owner of Wilmar Healthcare Systems, his wife Marla was a registered nurse and Island transported patients to and from the clinic. According to allegations, they not only paid patients for visiting the clinic in violation of the anti-kickback statute, but billed Medicare and Medicaid for vestibular testing that was never performed. The indictment also alleges the clinic billed Medicare and Medicaid under the provider number of a local doctor while that doctor was incarcerated on unrelated charges. From January 2006 through October 2009, Medicare and Medicaid paid Wilmar more than $4 million based on the alleged fraudulent claims.

If convicted, all three defendants face up to five years in federal prison and a $250,000 fine for conspiring to commit healthcare fraud and violating the anti-kickback statute. The Owuamas also face up to 10 years in prison and a $250,000 fine for the substantive healthcare fraud charges.

The investigation leading to the charges in this case was conducted by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services – Office of Inspector General and the Texas Attorney General’s Office Medicaid Fraud Control Unit. Special Assistant United States Attorney (SAUSA) Adrienne Frazior and AUSAs Andrew Leuchtmann and John Pearson are prosecuting the case.

http://www.yourhoustonnews.com/memorial/news/husband-wife-and-business-associate-charged-with-health-care-fraud/article_13e3906b-a9f5-5b62-973f-9b3c3b2b3f2a.html?mode=jqm


USDA awards millions for telemedicine

Monday, February 3, 2014

Prestige Wins Florida Medicaid Contracts After the Contracted was Contested by Care Access

With a billion dollars riding on the contested decision, Florida's Agency for Health Care Administration says it will award its Medicaid managed-care contract for Miami-Dade and Monroe counties to Prestige Health Choice.
The final order, signed by AHCA Secretary Liz Dudek on Friday, rejects a recommendation from an administrative law judge who held hearings in the case in November.  The judge, John Van Laningham, wrote that the corporate structure of Prestige Health Choice did not meet the definition for a "provider service network," or PSN.
Care Access, the company that filed the protest that led to the hearings, issued a statement Monday expressing disappointment. The company plans to file an appeal with the First District Court of Appeal in Tallahassee, the statement says.
Each region of the state must offer a PSN as a choice for Medicaid enrollment, in addition to HMOs. So if Prestige was not a true PSN, then the contract would have to be awarded to a competitor. Care Access PSN, which brought the protest that led to the hearing, stood to inherit the contract if Prestige were not eligible.
Van Laningham said Prestige did not have majority ownership by doctors or other health-care providers, a requirement for designation as a PSN.   Florida True Health, a company formed by two insurers, Florida Blue and AmeriHealth Caritas, owns 40 percent of Prestige. In addition, the judge said, Florida True Health holds an option to purchase the other 60 percent of shares.
Another 13 percent of Prestige is owned by Florida Health Choice Network, which is a consortium of neighborhood health centers. Van Laningham ruled that that Florida Health Choice Network is not a Medicaid provider, so therefore Prestige could not qualify as a PSN.  His decision was issued on Jan. 2, and Health News Florida filed this report.
State agencies and boards can overrule the recommendations of hearing officers if they can cite specific errors in the legal reasoning used to arrive at a decision. They cannot override findings of fact.
In its ruling, AHCA said Van Laningham had misconstrued two sections of the law that established the statewide managed-care Medicaid program.
AHCA went ahead and signed a contract with Prestige to enroll patients in Miami-Dade, along with seven  other regions of the state (see list of plans by region). The three regions in which other PSNs were chosen were Region 2, Panhandle, Better Health Plan; Region 4, Northeast Florida,  First Coast Advantage; and Region 10, Broward County, South Florida Community Care Network.
Frank Reiner, attorney for Care Access, says the law requires AHCA to hold off on issuing the contract until the 1st District Court has ruled in the coming appeal. Health News Florida raised that question with AHCA Monday afternoon, but had not yet heard back by 6 p.m.
Miami-Dade has been hotly contested because it has the most Medicaid enrollees, and therefore the most potential new customers, for whom the state pays the premiums.  The Miami-Dade contract is expected to pay about $1 billion over five years, a Care Access spokeswoman said.
The Legislature created the law in 2011 that requires virtually all Medicaid beneficiaries -- including those in long-term care -- to enroll in a managed-care plan, either an HMO or a PSN. The Long-Term-Care rollout is under way, and the other beneficiaries will be shifted between May and August of this year.
The law does away with "fee-for-service" Medicaid payments, in which doctors, hospitals and other providers directly billed the state. Amid the gush of claims, the state found it difficult to prevent fraud and abuse. By privatizing the program -- turning management of treatment and payment over to managed-care plans -- Medicaid becomes a regulator, rather than a direct payer.
While HMOs and PSNs may seem similar from the point of view of the patient, an HMO is a commercial operation that is dually licensed by AHCA and the Office of Insurance Regulation. A PSN is a health-care network owned and run by the health-care professionals who treat the patients.
More information on the Statewide Medicaid Managed Medical Assistance Program is available here.

Florida prepares to open its own health insurance exchange

Florida moves to open a state-run exchange

Florida may soon be operating its own health insurance exchange. The state has become a well known opponent of the Affordable Care Act , going so far as to seek the dismantling of the federal health care reform law through the Supreme Court as well as banning insurance navigators from working in the state. The state has missed its deadline to develop and operate a working exchange last year, meaning that a federal exchange has been set up for the state’s residents. Now, however, Florida Health Choices may soon be offering coverage.

Exchange finally shows signs of life after years of dormancy

Florida health insuranceFlorida Health Choices was first established through state law in 2008. Since then, however, little has been done in regards to developing the exchange. Most of Florida’s legislative focus has been committed to opposing the health care reform law, but the state has found little success in this endeavor. State officials suggest that allowing the federal government to manage the health insurance market is dangerous and claim that the state should have more authority over the market. As such, Florida Health Choices is preparing to open itself to the public.

State-run exchange will not compete with the federal government

There is no news concerning which of the state’s insurance companies will be providing coverage through the state-run exchange. Rose Naff, CEO of Florida Health Choices, claims that the majority of Floridians are not purchasing coverage through the federal insurance exchange. Instead, these people are purchasing coverage through the private market. Naff suggests that the state-run health insurance exchange will not be competing with the federal government when it comes to selling policies.
STATE-RUN EXCHANGE EXPECTED TO BECOME OPERATIONAL IN EARLY FEBRUARY
Naff anticipates that the launch of the state-run exchange is only “a few days” away. The exchange is expected to begin operation in early to mid-February and will provide subsidies for consumers that can help them acquire the insurance coverage they need. The state-run exchange is expected to operate in a similar fashion to exchanges in other states, with Florida officials keen to ensure that the federal government has little control over the exchange itself.

Innovative Pitt Competition Aims to Solve Health Problems through Patient Engagement

PITTSBURGH – In a creative, community-wide competition to spark fresh ideas that engage people in their own health care, the University of Pittsburgh is offering $300,000 in funding to three winners in its first Pitt Innovation Challenge, or PInCh.
Just as a reality TV show gives contestants an opportunity to share their inventions, PInCh will give scientists and other community members a venue to be creative and develop new ideas, said CTSI director Steven Reis, M.D., who also is associate vice chancellor for clinical research, health sciences, and a professor of medicine at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine. PInCh’s inaugural question is: “How do we empower individuals to take control of their own health outcomes?”
“Instead of trying to figure out the molecular mechanisms of hypertension, for example, the team might try to figure out how to reduce the rate of high blood pressure in a specific region,” Reis said. “We want to encourage researchers to approach their work in a different way. Rather than conducting experiments focused on scientific details, they must look at the big picture to try to solve a problem that has public health or clinical importance.”
According to PInCh program director John Maier, M.D., Ph.D., director of research and development and assistant professor, Department of Family Medicine, Pitt School of Medicine, the first step in the competition requires submitting a two-minute video by March 2 that introduces the team, defines the health problem that is being tackled and briefly outlines the creative solution. Early round winners will be invited to a final round of judging in May at a public event in which teams will make short presentations to a panel of judges.
“This will be a great opportunity to get new or risky ideas in front of judges who have experience in science, business, technology and other fields, so participation itself should be rewarding and fun,” Maier said. “We plan to have a ‘People’s Choice’ award, too, so everyone will have a chance to vote for projects that appeal to them.”
Anyone can enter, and teams that bring together collaborators from different perspectives, institutions and disciplines are encouraged, but at least one member of the team must be a Pitt faculty member. If needed, PInCh organizers will help community members connect with a member of the faculty. The solution could be a device, a software application, an intervention strategy or any other approach that could address the health problem the team identifies.
“We hope to de-risk wild ideas to solve clinical or public health problems by providing funding and project management to take them to the next level,” Reis said. “We think some amazing ideas will come out of this process, and we hope the PInCh model can be used in future competitions to stimulate innovative solutions to challenging issues.”


A Sustainable Healthcare System Depends on Equal Access to Quality Education

“Without continual growth and progress, such words as improvement, achievement, and success have no meaning.” – Benjamin Franklin
HCMS ChainHCMS
Health Care Management Systems was created to provide free, high quality, on-demand learning to all of those involved in the frontlines of healthcare!

Why?

Because we have proven that “equal access to high quality education” is the missing link in the healthcare equation.  Yes, proven through a unique double blind study that you have probably never heard of…
You see, this story begins about 3 years ago on the Texas gulf coast when two unlikely partners teamed up to change the way managed care was delivered to a certain Medicare population.
The strategy was devised from a simple physics theory – to influence the greatest amount of change in the shortest amount of time possible – equal pressure must be applied in all directions.
Education was the single greatest variable that was common to all groups – so our hypothesis was built on the assumption that through simultaneous and continuous education at the point of care, we could make a measurable impact on both the cost and the experience of care!
The project was a huge success from both a financial and cultural perspective. Two years later that “little experiment” is now out funding larger markers  – all without ever auditing a chart!

Lighting in a Bottle –
Okay, so our hypothesis was a success, but where do go from here? We were so amazed and excited about the outcome that we wanted to find a way to offer it to everyone – anywhere, anytime, anyplace and on any device!
So, we developed a vehicle: Global Health Care Management Systems (globalhcms.org) – an innovative learning platform that can deliver our proven education to everyone on the frontlines!
Anyone involved who wants to learn is invited to join the HCMS Academy!
To ensure that this tool will continue to be available to all of those we serve, we have teamed up with other healthcare leaders to provide employer sponsored learning as well.
A big THANK YOU to all of our partners and sponsors – without them none of this would be possible….
To learn more about our pilot program please visit: www.ermconsultinginc.com.
To find out how you can partner with us to ensure equal access to quality education email: kgifford@ermconsultinginc.com.


How Do I Sign Up?

HCMS ACADEMY-

We invite everyone currently working on the frontlines or those contemplating a new career in healthcare to register for the HCMS Academy. Register for free courses and receive certifications in Medicare Risk Adjustment, ICD-10 Coding and Rapid Practice Innovation. As a member of the Academy you are invited to join our conversation on the “Innovation X-Change.” The X-Change provides a secure, HIPPA compliant meeting space for visionaries to share ideas and collaborate on future projects. Join a group or start your own. Register today at www.globalhcms.org – What are you waiting on – it’s totally FREE!

SPONSOR E-LEARNING-

Are you involved in health care? If so, we invite you to join us in our mission! By sponsoring e-learning for your employees or industry partners you can help ensure that everyone has equal access to high quality education.
By partnering with HCMS, you extend our proven education to your organization at no cost and we are able to provide you with state of the art analytics including dashboards to track implementation and progress across large organizations in real time. This system was built on an API that accepts up to 5 data sources which potentially allows us to measure and analyze financial, educational and utilization data together for the first time. All of this at a fraction of the cost of traditional analytics.
To learn more about how we can partner for a better tomorrow, please contact: kgifford@ermconsultinginc.com



Thursday, January 30, 2014

NYC gets cash to link 6 million patients with their health records

6 million patients to get their health records linked

Seven New York City health systems have been awarded $7 million in efforts to spur data sharing initiatives and more effective patient recruitment for clinical trials. 

The funding, provided by the Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute, or PCORI, will establish a clinical data research network in New York City, one of 29 such networks nationwide, officials say. These networks together will form PCORnet, the National Patient-Center Clinical Research Network, a $93.5 million patient-centered research initiative. 

The New York City Clinical Data Research Network, or NYC-CDRN, is a consortium composed of 22 regional organizations. The network, officials explain, will share capabilities and develop systems to support data-networking efforts and advance patient-centered research. It will initially focus its efforts on identifying individuals with diabetes, obesity and cystic fibrosis, and will partner with patients and clinicians through disease-specific community workgroups. 

"This contract is an exciting opportunity for leading New York City institutions to work together, through patient-centered research, for the health of the people who live here," said Rainu Kaushal, MD, chair of Weill Cornell's department of healthcare policy and research and the project's principal investigator, in a press release. "It validates New York's infrastructural advances in clinical data sharing."

[See also: Kaiser eyes outcomes with new network.]

The NYC-CDRN builds on six existing National Institutes of Health Clinical and Translational Science Award Centers that already work on collaborative research, data sharing and patient engagement. The CTSA centers are at Albert Einstein College of Medicine of Yeshiva University/Montefiore Medical Center, College of Physicians and Surgeons at Columbia University, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, NYU School of Medicine, Rockefeller University and Weill Cornell. The project also has received support from the New York State Department of Health and builds on infrastructure established by two New York health information exchanges, Healthix and the Bronx Regional Health Information Organization.

The NYC-CDRN network will link medical records for 6 million New York City residents, and all records will be anonymized to protect patient privacy. Over the next 18 months, award recipients will expand and improve their individuals systems and further work to standardize data. Project officials say the scale of the data-sharing between institutions will make it far easier and faster to enroll patients in clinical trials and conduct comparative effectiveness and clinical outcomes research. The goal is to allow patients and providers to have access to evidence-based information they can use to make clinical choices and ultimately to improve healthcare.

PCORI announced back in December it had approved $93.5 million to support the 29 clinical research data networks. 

Earlier this January, it was announced that Kaiser Permanente would be one of these 29 receiving $7 million to build a clinical network focused on obesity, cancer and heart disease.  



United States: CMS Proposed Rule Would Modify Risk Adjustment Data Collection, Data Validation Audits With Some Material Effects


The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services' proposal for risk adjustment data collection demonstrates the agency's continued concern that Medicare Advantage Organizations' activities are resulting in more "intense" coding, and higher risk scores affecting payments, as compared to Medicare fee-for-service.
Among the proposed policy changes in the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services' (CMS's) proposed rule (Proposed Rule) are revisions to risk adjustment data collection requirements as well as risk adjustment data validation (RADV) audits.  Although many of the proposed changes are procedural and not likely to have a material impact on industry stakeholders, a few of the proposals, including limits on medical record reviews and changes to risk adjustment data validation appeals, could prove to be more significant.
Comments on the Proposed Rule, which was published in the Federal Register on January 10, 2014, are due to CMS by 5 p.m. EST on March 7, 2014.

Medical Record Reviews

In recent years, Medicare Advantage (MA) Organizations have sometimes reviewed medical records to identify and submit to CMS additional diagnoses codes that were documented in the medical records but were not submitted by providers in their claims or encounter data.  These diagnoses could have the effect of raising the risk score of the MA Plan-enrolled beneficiary, potentially enhancing CMS's risk-adjusted payment to the MA Organization.  In the Proposed Rule, CMS proposes to require that any retrospective review be "designed to determine the accuracy of diagnoses" submitted by the provider in addition to identifying diagnoses that were not submitted and that would warrant additional payments.  According to CMS, this restriction is part of an effort to enhance the accuracy of risk adjustment data.
CMS's proposal would apparently address the type of MA Organization activity that was alleged in a recent False Claims Act settlement (United States ex rel. _____ v. SCAN Health Plan)that involved an alleged retrospective chart review.CMS's proposal demonstrates its continued concern that MA Organizations' activities are resulting in more "intense" coding, and higher risk scores, for MA Organizations as compared to Medicare fee-for-service (FFS).  CMS has already signaled that it intends to rein in some aspects of MA Organizations' use of so-called "prospective" risk adjustment programs—specifically, submission of risk adjustment codes based on risk assessment visits conducted in the home.  (Although the CY 2014 "call letter" released in April 2013 indicated concerns regarding these house call programs, CMS does not address them specifically in the Proposed Rule.)

Risk Adjustment Data Validation Appeals

The Proposed Rule also would modify the RADV administrative appeals process.  A few changes are procedural in nature.  Under the current rules, there are separate appeals procedures for medical record review determination appeals and RADV payment error calculation appeals.  CMS proposes to consolidate these two types of appeals.  The Proposed Rule also reaffirms and expands the list of the types of issues that are not eligible for appeal; the current prohibition on challenges to the payment error calculation methodology for RADV audits would be expanded to include a prohibition on the medical record review determination methodology.
CMS also states that it will not necessarily publish the RADV payment calculation methodology each year, but will publish it only if there is a change that would require publication.  CMS does not address when or through what mechanism it will publish the amount of the so-called "FFS Adjuster," described in the February 2012 Notice of Final Payment Error Calculation Methodology for Part C Medicare Advantage Risk Adjustment Data Validation Contract-Level Audits (Methodology Notice), or whether CMS will reveal the analysis behind the calculation.  The FFS Adjuster, according to CMS in the Methodology Notice, "accounts for the fact that the documentation standard used in RADV audits to determine a contract's payment error (medical records) is different from the documentation standard used to develop the Part C risk-adjustment model (FFS claims)."

Conclusion

Risk adjustment continues to be significant to MA Organizations' financial performance and presents significant audit and False Claims Act risks.  Therefore, Plan Sponsors should consider the implications of CMS's proposal on their current and anticipated operations.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.