Showing posts with label Risk Scores. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Risk Scores. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 22, 2020

Six Reasons Your Risk Scores are Inaccurate

By Kameron Gifford, CPC


As we enter the third quarter of 2020, healthcare organizations have been struggling for months to balance priorities and resources while navigating new technologies and processes to keep employees and patients safe during the coronavirus.

The AAFP and MGMA both recently reported, “Medical group practices of all sizes and specialties have felt the direct and indirect financial impact... On average, patient volumes have dropped 60% nationally since the start of the pandemic attributing to a 55% decrease in fee-for-service revenues.  

Medical practices are not alone, hospital revenue is dropping by an average of $1.4 billion per day as COVID-19 continues to impact patient volumes, according to Crowe RCA Benchmarking analysis.

Risk Scores and Value-Based Payments
As more and more healthcare organizations are moving away from traditional fee-for-service payment models, how will this decrease in utilization impact risk scores and value-based payments in the future?

According to Avalere, the deferral of care has resulted in fewer claims and diagnoses among Medicare Advantage (MA) enrollees, which will likely lead to a 3%–7% reduction in 2021 risk scores and lower plan payments.

Mitigating the Impact to Risk and Quality
Inaccurate risk scores not only impact payments to Medicare Advantage plans, but also skew the costs in ACOs and hinder performance in value-based contracts. This further underscores the need to capture an accurate health status on every patient.

What steps can organizations take today to achieve accurate risk scores and mitigate future losses?

Common Errors Leading to Inaccurate Risk Scores
The 2020 ICD-10-CM code set includes 72,184 diagnoses and the 2021 ICD-10-CM code set includes 72,616 diagnoses. With less than 14% of ICD-10-CM codes mapping to an HCC, lack of specificity is the most common cause of inaccurate risk scores.  

Review the six most common coding errors below that lead to inaccurate risk scores and payments.



E11.9 – Type 2 Diabetes without Complications


According to the most recent data released by MedPAC on July 17, 2020, 28.2% of Medicare beneficiaries had a diagnosis of diabetes on a claim in 2019. Roughly 70% of these mapped to HCC 18, Diabetes with chronic complications, while 30% of these mapped to HCC 19, Diabetes without complications.

How does your coding for diabetes compare to MedPAC data? What percentage of patients are coded as E11.9 by primary care providers? What percentage are coded as E11.9 by specialists such as hospitalists and endocrinologists?

Per ICD-10 Guidelines, approximately 30 conditions have an assumed relationship with type 2 diabetes. Meaning, they are always coded as a complication unless the medical record explicitly states otherwise.

Examples include:
  • Type 2 Diabetes with CKD, E11.22
  • Type 2 Diabetes with dermatitis, E11.620
  • Type 2 Diabetes with foot ulcer, E11.621
  • Type 2 Diabetes with gastroparesis, E11.43
  • Type 2 Diabetes with hyperglycemia, E11.65
  • Type 2 Diabetes with hypoglycemia, E11.649
  • Type 2 Diabetes with mononeuropathy, E11.41
  • Type 2 Diabetes with myasthenia, E11.44
  • Type 2 Diabetes with nephropathy, E11.21
  • Type 2 Diabetes with neuralgia, E11.42
  • Type 2 Diabetes with neuropathy, E11.40
  • Type 2 Diabetes with PAD, E11.51
  • Type 2 Diabetes with periodontal disease, E11.630
  • Type 2 Diabetes with polyneuropathy, E11.42
  • Type 2 Diabetes with retinopathy, E11.319

Review 5 – 10 encounters per provider. What percentage of encounters coded as E11.9, had a complication documented in the medical record? Target education, prospective chart checks and pre-billing review per the results.

How it Happens
Several factors contribute to the high error rate related to coding for E11.9. The two most common reasons are failure to update the diagnosis as the disease progresses and failure to follow the ICD-10 Guidelines for “with”.

Why it Matters
The 2020 CMS-HCC RAF for HCC 19 is 0.105 and the 2020 CMS-HCC RAF for HCC 18 is 0.302. That is a loss of 0.197 per error. This adds up quickly across populations, accounting for annual average losses of $60,000 - $130,000 per 1000 MA beneficiaries.

F32.9, Major Depression, Single Episode, Unspecified


According to the most recent data released by MedPAC on July 17, 2020, 11.3% of MA beneficiaries were diagnosed with a condition mapping to HCC 59, Major Depressive, Bipolar or Paranoid Disorders.  

According to CMS, mood disorders (mainly MDD and bipolar disorder) are the second leading cause of disability in Medicare patients under the age of 65. Depression is a major predictor of the onset of stroke, diabetes, and heart disease; it raises patients’ risk of developing coronary heart disease and the risk of dying from a heart attack nearly threefold.

Overall, the economic burden of the disease is significant to managed care organizations, with direct medical costs estimated at $3.5 million per 1000 plan members with depression.

Identify Errors and Opportunities

From a coding perspective, MDD is classified by episode, severity, and remission.
According to AMJMED, 75% to 90% of patients experience >1 episode of depression. This suggests that only 10 - 25% of MDD diagnoses would be assigned to F32 with the remaining 75 – 90% being classified as F33.

Analyze your coding for MDD. What percentage of MDD diagnoses are single episodes (F32.x) vs. recurrent episodes (F33.x) What percentage of single episodes are classified as “unspecified” (F32.9) when a PHQ-9 was completed and/or the documentation supported a more specific diagnosis? What percentage of patients taking an SSRI or other antidepressant have a current diagnosis to support medical necessity?

Review 5-10 encounters per provider with a diagnosis of F32.9. Was the correct diagnosis assigned? Target education, prospective chart checks and pre-billing review per the results.

Why it Matters
From a risk adjustment perspective, F32.9, is the only MDD diagnosis that does not map to an HCC. The 2020 CMS-HCC RAF for HCC 59, Major Depressive, Bipolar and Paranoid Disorders is 0.309. Missed opportunities relating to the use of F32.9 average 20% across populations accounting for an average annual loss revenue of $77,500 per 1000 members.

How it Happens
Two factors contribute to the high use of this code. First, the GEM files mapped the ICD-9 code 311 to the ICD-10 code F32.9 and these files were widely used by EHR vendors. The second factor involves the number of boxes providers must check in their EHR to get to the more specific MDD diagnosis.

One way to avoid these extra clicks is by typing the diagnosis code directly into the search box of your EHR. For example, typing F32.0 (MDD, single episode, mild) vs depression will reduce clicks from 13 to 4 and reduce search results from 800+ to 1. Searching for F33.0 (MDD, recurrent, mild) vs recurrent depression will save even more clicks with the same results.

I25.9, Chronic Ischemic Heart Disease and I25.10, CAD without Angina


According to the NIH, an estimated 10 million adults in the United States carry the diagnosis and ischemic heart disease remains the number one cause of death for male as well as female patients. Furthermore, the increasing survival with the use of modern therapies has produced an aging population where more than 20% of women and 35% of men above the age of 80 have coronary artery disease.

Identify Errors and Opportunities
From a coding perspective, chronic ischemic heart disease is classified to category I25 and CAD is further classified as with or without angina.

Analyze your coding of chronic ischemic heart disease (I25.9) and CAD without angina (I25.10). Depending on your results you may also want to include old MI (I25.2) and chest pain (R07.9) in your search.

Review 5-10 encounters per provider. How many of these patients had evidence of angina documented, history of CABG and/or a current prescription for nitroglycerin? Target education, prospective chart checks and pre-billing reviews per the results.

How it Happens
The term stable ischemic heart disease (SIHD) is often used synonymously with chronic coronary artery disease (CAD) and encompasses a variety of conditions. Many EHR’s include an IMO to assist providers in searching for codes. This “tool” adds multiple code descriptions for each ICD-10 code and can increase search results by 70%. Many providers do not have the time to search dozens of code descriptions for multiple diagnoses prior to closing their note. This often results in the selection of the first or second result, even when a more specific diagnosis is supported by the documentation.

Why it Matters
From a risk adjustment perspective, I25.9 and I25.10 are included in the Rx-HCC Model V05, but not in the CMS HCC Model V24. However, CAD with Angina (I25.110 – I25.119) and Angina (I20.0 – 120.9, I23.7) are all included in the CMS HCC Model V24. The 2020 RAF for HCC 87 is 0.195 and HCC 88 is 0.135.

According to the CMS Chronic Disease Warehouse, 10,238,321 (or 17.1%) Medicare beneficiaries had a diagnosis of ischemic heart disease. While the most recent MedPAC data published on July 17, 2020 reveals only a 4% prevalence rate among MA beneficiaries in the same year.

Missed opportunities relating to the use of I25.9, I25.10, I25.2 and/or R07.9 average 25% across populations accounting for an average annual loss of $64,638 - $93,366 per 1000 MA members. 

I49.9, Cardiac arrythmia, unspecified


According to the most recent data released by MedPAC on July 17, 2020, 11.4% of Medicare Advantage members had a diagnosis that mapped into HCC 96, Specified Heart Arrythmias.

In the CMS-HCC Model V24, 18 ICD-10 codes are mapped into HCC 96.

Examples include:
  • AV Block, Complete, I44.2
  • SVT, I47.1
  • Paroxysmal A. Fib, I48.0
  • A. Flutter, I49.92
  • Sick Sinus, I49.5


Identify Errors and Opportunities
Analyze your coding for cardiac arrythmias. What percentage of encounters/claims are coded with I49.9, Cardiac arrhythmia, unspecified when the medical record supported a more specific diagnosis? 

You may also want to include the use the ICD-10-CM code Z95.810, Presence of automatic (implantable) cardiac defibrillator, in your analysis. Target education, prospective chart checks and pre-billing reviews per the results.

How it Happens
AHA Coding Clinic recently updated their guidance on coding for sick sinus syndrome treated with a pacemaker. This change in guidance has led to an increased number of opportunities identified in HCC 96. Additional opportunities are identified from diagnostic test results and specialists’ reports.

Why it Matters
I49.9, Cardiac arrhythmia, unspecified is not included in the 2020 CMS-HCC Model V24.
Missed opportunities relating to HCC 96 average 20% across populations accounting for average annual lost revenue of $67,214 per 1,000 MA beneficiaries.


N18.9, CKD, unspecified


According to the CMS Chronic Condition Warehouse, there were 9,360,944 Medicare beneficiaries (15.6%) with a diagnosis of CKD on a claim in 2018. However, a review of the most recent data released by MedPAC on July 17, 2020, does not include CKD, meaning the prevalence for MA members in the same year was less than 1.5%.

Why Is Chronic Kidney Disease Important?


The total Medicare spending on both CKD and ESRD patients was in excess of $120 billion in 2017. For identified CKD (not ESRD) the total Medicare expenditure was $84 billion.

Identify Errors and Opportunities
Analyze your coding for CKD. What percentage of encounters/claims are coded with N18.9, CKD, unspecified, vs. a more specific code such as N18.3 and/or N18.4?
You may also want to include the ICD-10 code N28.9, disorder of kidney and ureter, unspecified, in your analysis.

Review 5-10 encounters per provider. What percentage of encounters/claims are coded with an unspecified diagnosis such as N18.9 and/or N28.9, when a more specific diagnosis is supported by the medical record? Target education, prospective chart checks and pre-billing reviews per the results.

How it Happens
There are several factors that contribute to this large opportunity. Lack of documentation is the most common reason. CKD must be staged by the provider. Pasting a copy of the patient’s most recent labs into the current encounter supports the provider’s medical decision making but does not replace the need for the stage to be documented.
The fluctuating nature of the disease also contributes to the lack of specificity in coding, as providers are less likely to update.  

Historically, multiple terms have been applied to chronic kidney disease (CKD), eg, chronic renal insufficiency, chronic renal disease, and chronic renal failure, the National Kidney Foundation Kidney Disease Outcomes Quality Initiative™ (NKF KDOQI™) has defined the all-encompassing term, CKD. This recent change in terminology also contributes to the size of the opportunity. The IMO search tool in EHR’s will lead providers using older terminology such as, renal insufficiency, to select a diagnosis of N28.9

CKD stage 3 was removed from the HCC model in 2014 and this likely contributed to the decrease in coding by MA plans as well. CMS reversed course in PY 2019, and added HCC 138, CKD stage 3, back into the model.

Why it Matters
Missed opportunities relating to HCC 138, CKD stage 3, average 60% across MA populations accounting for annual average lost revenue of $73,625 per 1000 members.






Want to learn more? Visit www.erm365.org and www.ermconsultinginc.com

ERM Consulting Inc. works with healthcare organizations across the country to optimize their risk adjustment operations.
·




Tuesday, July 14, 2020

Save 50% on ALL Workshops and Coding Tools




Are you looking for the best education available in risk adjustment, value-based payments and/or CDI?

Good News - You have found it!

Join us for a day of risk adjustment, catch up with colleagues over lunch, and get the best tools in the industry for FREE!

Do you need CMEs or CEUs? We have that too!

All Workshops are approved by the American Medical Association, American Academy of Family Practice and the American Academy of Professional Coders.

Register your team ( 3 or more) today to save 10% on any 2020 Workshop!

Take advantage of Early Bird pricing and Save $100!

Overview:
  • Vast changes are coming to the way we purchase healthcare.
  • What should your team be doing now to be successful in the world of value-based payments? 
  • How do HCCs impact benchmarks and quality scores?
  • Review the CMS-HCC Model V24 for risk adjustment in 2020 and 2021. 
  • Discuss the importance of managing HCCs year over year. What resources are available from CMS to help? 
  • Take a deep dive into the 20 most common HCCs per Medpac data. 
  • Common GAPS in claims and encounter data that lead to inaccurate risk scores. 

Who Should Attend?
-Providers - MDs, DOs, PAs, and NPs
-Medical Directors - Medicare Advantage, ACOs, CPC+ and Medicaid
-Hospitals and Academic Medical Centers
-Medical Coders, Billers and CDI Specialists
-Executive Leaders, Administrators, Directors and Managers
-MSO and IPA Teams
-Rural Health Centers, FQHCs and Community Health Centers
-Health Alliance Members and Medical Society Members
-Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and Commercial Plans
  

Each Attendee will Receive ($130):
 - Color copy of the presentation
 - CME from AAFP and AMA
 - CEU from AAPC





To SPONSOR an EVENT
Please email Kameron Gifford


Early Bird Pricing and Group Discounts
Register NOW to save $100 with Early Bird Pricing!
Bring the WHOLE TEAM!
 Register 3 and save 10% on your order!





Order HCC Coding Tools for your Team and Save 50% 


Is Your Team Risk Ready?
Arm Your Team For Combat This Risk Adjustment Season!


Tuesday, June 30, 2020

Coding for Diabetes with Complications


Question:

If a patient has multiple diabetic complications, will coding all of them have an impact on the risk score?

Answer:

  • Credit is given once for each HCC category captured within the calendar year (after hierarchies are implied).
  • Depending on the specific complication, additional credit may be given for the HCC of the complication.




Visit ERM365 to learn more



Tuesday, June 23, 2020

Data Submission Deadlines for Medicare Advantage



Question: 


When does CMS run the risk score model to calculate risk scores for Medicare Advantage? What is the deadline for submitting claims data? 

Answer: 


The chart above highlights when CMS will the risk model to calculate risk scores for the PY 2021 Initial Run. Dates of service included and data submission deadlines are also highlighted above.


Visit www.ERM365.org to learn more.


Friday, January 16, 2015

FAQ - Calculation of member months for the Cost-Sharing Reductions Reconciliation simplified methodology



Q. On November 21, 2014, HHS clarified that a plan benefit year could begin as late as March
31, 2014 for the purpose of establishing member months to meet the credibility threshold
required by the cost-sharing reduction reconciliation simplified methodology. Does the new
March 31, 2014 deadline include people who applied or tried to apply by March 31, 2014, but
whose enrollments were not effectuated?

A: Yes. A Qualified Health Plan issuer assessing whether enrollment meets the credibility
threshold for the simplified methodology may count members who applied or tried to apply by
March 31, 2014, but whose enrollment did not become effective until later because of technology
challenges. This includes members whose applications were not processed until after March 31,
2014, postponing their start date until May, and members who received a special enrollment
period because Exchange issues prevented them from filing an application by March 31, 2014.

The cost-sharing reduction reconciliation simplified methodology provided in 45 CFR
156.430(c)(4) allows issuers to develop a set of effective cost-sharing parameters based on the
average experience of enrollees in a standard plan. HHS in 45 CFR 156.430(c)(4)(v) set a
minimum of 12,000 member months per benefit year in the standard plan to establish a credible
claims data base on which to measure cost-sharing parameters.

Because of 2014 enrollment delays, we will consider this standard met if at least 12,000 member
months are accumulated for enrollees, each of whom applied or tried to apply to the plan
beginning no later than March 31, 2014 and remained in the plan until the end of the benefit year
on December 31, 2014. This includes members who received special enrollment periods that
resulted in an effective date up to but not later than May 31, 2014.

Issuers that selected the simplified methodology but do not meet the foregoing 12,000-member
month credibility standard must use the Actuarial Value simplified methodology described at 45
CFR 156.430 (c)(4) (v).

 FAQ - January 13, 2015      https://www.regtap.info/uploads/library/APTC_FAQ_CSRRecon_MemberMnths_5CR_011315.pdf

Thursday, August 7, 2014

HHS Report Finds Medicare Advantage Plans Exaggerate Members’ Diseases To Make More Money

AUG 07, 2014
This copyrighted story comes from . All rights reserved.
Many Medicare Advantage health plans routinely over bill the government for treating elderly patients — and have done it for years, a federal study shows.
Department of Health and Human Services researchers found that many plans exaggerate how sick their patients are and how much they cost to treat. Medicare expects to pay the privately run plans — an alternative to traditional Medicare —$160 billion this year.
The HHS study does not accuse any specific insurers of wrongdoing or name  the plans that were scrutinized. But the researchers offer the most comprehensive evidence to date that suspect billing practices have been common across much of the Medicare Advantage industry and are likely to get worse unless officials crack down.
“Further policy changes will likely be necessary,” the study concludes.
Congress created Medicare Advantage in 2003 to encourage private insurance companies to venture into the senior care market. The plans now insure 16 million elderly and disabled people, nearly a third of those eligible for Medicare. They are popular with seniors because they often provide extra benefits, such as eyeglasses and dental care, and can cost less out-of-pocket than standard Medicare.
Medicare pays the Advantage health plans higher rates for sicker patients and less for healthy people using a complex formula called a “risk score.” But the HHS study spells out several ways health plans have inflated those scores, from reporting surprisingly high levels of medical conditions such as alcohol or drug dependence to billing for an inordinately high number of patients with complications of diabetes.
Despite its broad implications for Medicare spending, the study by HHS researchers Richard Kronick and W. Pete Welch has attracted scant notice in Washington. It was quietly posted late last month on an online research site run by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, part of HHS.
Kronick directs the HHS Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, whose mission is to improve health care delivery. Welch works for the HHS Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation. The authors note that the study does not necessarily reflect HHS views, but both offices are influential in advising the government on policy matters.
CMS officials declined comment.  
“This is clearly impacting what taxpayers are paying for Medicare Advantage, I think, not in a good way,” said Dr. David Wennberg, a researcher at the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice who has studied Medicare billing trends.
Health care fraud expert Malcolm Sparrow, a professor at Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government, said the problems with billings based on risk scores reveal how “financial incentives” can improperly influence how medicine is practiced.
“The problem seems significant,” he said.
The new study amplifies the findings of a Center for Public Integrity investigation published in June. The investigation found that Medicare made nearly $70 billion in “improper” payments — mostly overcharges from inflated risk scores — to Medicare Advantage plans from 2008 through 2013. The center’s investigation also found that risk scores rose much faster in some health plans than others and that federal officials repeatedly yielded to industry pressure to minimize efforts to recoup overpayments.
Medicare Advantage plans are paid a set monthly fee for each patient based on the risk scores, and the government largely trusts the health plans to report the health status of people they enroll. About 70 medical conditions can boost payment rates.
Clare Krusing, a spokeswoman for America’s Health Insurance Plans, the industry’s trade group, said the higher billing resulted from health plans working with patients “to understand their specific health conditions, and consequently make sure they get the care they need.”
“What was not highlighted (in the study) is the fact that these programs have demonstrated improved quality in patients’ health,” she wrote in an email.
However, the study concludes that people who join Medicare Advantage plans are healthier than those who remain on standard Medicare, which pays doctors and hospitals for each service they provide. The study also says it’s “unlikely” the higher payments health plans derive from diagnosing more medical conditions “are related to substantial health benefits.”
In short, the numbers of patients diagnosed with diseases which result in higher payments increased far faster at many Medicare Advantage health plans than among people on standard Medicare. Exaggerating the severity of a medical condition to raise fees is known in medical circles as “upcoding.”
For instance, “drug and alcohol dependence” is as much as eight times more common in the highest coding Medicare Advantage plans than among patients in standard Medicare.
Even more striking, according to the study, is how much higher reported diabetes rates have been in certain health plans than others. The study tracked rapid rises in many medical conditions from 2004, when risk scoring began, through last year, and made them public for the first time.
Overall, diabetes with serious complications, which pays higher rates, was reported up to five times more often among enrollees in some Medicare Advantage plans than among people on standard Medicare. Conditions such as major depression also were far more common in some plans than others.
Holly J. Cassano, a medical coding consultant in Florida, said the government’s decision to make the billing data public was “an enormous leap … in the right direction for continued transparency in all areas of health care.”
 “The main issue, now that it has been revealed, is ‘upcoding’, which no one likes to discuss, but the data is in black and white and speaks volumes,” Cassano, CEO of Accucode Consulting, wrote in an email.
Medicare Advantage enjoys solid political backing on Capitol Hill and has successfully fought back efforts by the Obama administration to make substantial cuts to its payment rates. Lobbying by the insurance industry and the fear of angering seniors also has largely quieted concerns in Congress that Medicare Advantage plans can be a poor value for taxpayers.
Congress recognized problems with Medicare Advantage coding as far back as 2005, when lawmakers directed CMS to find ways to cut back on rising, and presumably unjustified, risk scores. But CMS didn’t act until 2010, when it adjusted risk scores downward. The Affordable Care Act theoretically requires further reductions, but the political storm over the planned cuts has made their fate uncertain.  
CMS has cut back payment levels for several diseases that appear to have prompted upcoding by Medicare Advantage plans. But the study’s authors noted that health plans are likely to find new conditions to replace lost revenue.
Even though the study does not name plans, it says all those examined had at least 10,000 members and that one plan among the highest billers had more than 200,000 members. The study indicates that the longer patients stay in Medicare Advantage, the more their risk scores rose, suggesting that government’s failure to reel in coding has been costly.
The Center for Public Integrity has sought similar billing data from CMS for the past year as well as the names of Medicare Advantage plans that have been suspected of overbilling the government — and by how much. In late May, the Center sued the Department of Health and Human Services to make its Medicare Advantage audits and other related records public. The lawsuit is pending.
Last month, CMS published a draft regulation that would allow for “a formal process to recoup overpayments” made to the health plans. A final decision on the proposal is due by Nov. 1.

http://www.kaiserhealthnews.org/Stories/2014/August/07/Medicare-advantage-plans-exaggerate-diseases-to-make-money-says-study.aspx