Tuesday, May 14, 2013

(CMS-10062) Collection of Diagnostic Data from Medicare Advantage Organizations for Risk Adjusted Payments


DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND
HUMAN SERVICES
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid
Services
[Document Identifiers: CMS–R–70, CMS–R–
72, CMS–R–247, CMS–10287, CMS–R–43,
CMS–855(POH), CMS–2552–10, and CMS–
10062]
Agency Information Collection
Activities: Proposed Collection;
Comment Request
AGENCY: Centers for Medicare &
Medicaid Services, HHS.
In compliance with the requirement
of section 3506(c)(2)(A) of the
Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995, the
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid
Services (CMS) is publishing the
following summary of proposed
collections for public comment.
Interested persons are invited to send
comments regarding this burden
estimate or any other aspect of this
collection of information, including any
of the following subjects: (1) The
necessity and utility of the proposed
information collection for the proper
performance of the agency’s functions;
(2) the accuracy of the estimated
burden; (3) ways to enhance the quality,
utility, and clarity of the information to
be collected; and (4) the use of
automated collection techniques or
other forms of information technology to
minimize the information collection
burden.
1. Type of Information Collection
Request: Reinstatement with a change of
a previously approved collection; Title
of Information Collection: Information
Collection Requirements in HSQ–110,
Acquisition, Protection and Disclosure
of Peer review Organization Information
and Supporting Regulations in 42 CFR,
Sections 480.104, 480.105, 480.116, and
480.134; Use: The Peer Review
Improvement Act of 1982 authorizes
quality improvement organizations
VerDate Mar<15>2010 18:05 May 09, 2013 Jkt 229001 PO 00000 Frm 00037 Fmt 4703 Sfmt 4703 E:\FR\FM\10MYN1.SGM 10MYN1 mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with NOTICES
Federal Register /Vol. 78, No. 91 / Friday, May 10, 2013 /Notices 27401
(QIOs), formally known as peer review
organizations (PROs), to acquire
information necessary to fulfill their
duties and functions and places limits
on disclosure of the information. The
QIOs are required to provide notices to
the affected parties when disclosing
information about them. These
requirements serve to protect the rights
of the affected parties. The information
provided in these notices is used by the
patients, practitioners and providers to:
obtain access to the data maintained and
collected on them by the QIOs; add
additional data or make changes to
existing QIO data; and reflect in the
QIO’s record the reasons for the QIO’s
disagreeing with an individual’s or
provider’s request for amendment.:
Form Number: CMS–R–70 (OCN: 0938–
0426); Frequency: Reporting—On
occasion; Affected Public: Business or
other for-profits; Number of
Respondents: 400; Total Annual
Responses: 21,200; Total Annual Hours:
42,400. (For policy questions regarding
this collection contact Coles Mercier at
410–786–2112. For all other issues call
410–786–1326.)
2. Type of Information Collection
Request: Reinstatement without change
of a previously approved collection;
Title of Information Collection:
Information Collection Requirements in
42 CFR 478.18, 478.34, 478.36, 478.42,
QIO Reconsiderations and Appeals; Use:
In the event that a beneficiary, provider,
physician, or other practitioner does not
agree with the initial determination of a
Quality Improvement Organization
(QIO) or a QIO subcontractor, it is
within that party’s rights to request
reconsideration. The information
collection requirements at 42 CFR
478.18, 478.34, 478.36, and 478.42,
contain procedures for QIOs to use in
reconsideration of initial
determinations. The information
requirements contained in these
regulations are imposed on QIOs to
provide information to parties
requesting the reconsideration. These
parties will use the information as
guidelines for appeal rights in instances
where issues are actively being
disputed. Form Number: CMS–R–72
(OCN: 0938–0443); Frequency:
Reporting—On occasion; Affected
Public: Individuals or Households and
Business or other for-profit institutions;
Number of Respondents: 2,590; Total
Annual Responses: 5,228; Total Annual
Hours: 2,822. (For policy questions
regarding this collection contact Coles
Mercier at 410–786–2112. For all other
issues call 410–786–1326.)
3. Type of Information Collection
Request: Reinstatement with a change of
a previously approved collection; Title
of Information Collection: Expanded
Coverage for Diabetes Outpatient Self-
Management Training Services and
Supporting Regulations Contained in 42
CFR 410.141, 410.142, 410.143, 410.144,
410.145, 410.146, 414.63; Use:
According to the National Health and
Nutrition Examination Survey
(NHANES), as many as 18.7 percent of
Americans over age 65 are at risk for
developing diabetes. The goals in the
management of diabetes are to achieve
normal metabolic control and reduce
the risk of micro- and macro-vascular
complications. Numerous epidemiologic
and interventional studies point to the
necessity of maintaining good glycemic
control to reduce the risk of the
complications of diabetes. Despite this
knowledge, diabetes remains the leading
cause of blindness, lower extremity
amputations and kidney disease
requiring dialysis. Diabetes and its
complications are primary or secondary
factors in an estimated 9 percent of
hospitalizations (Aubert, RE, et al.,
Diabetes-related hospitalizations and
hospital utilization. In: Diabetes in
America. 2nd ed. National Institutes of
Health, National Institute of Diabetes
and Digestive and Kidney Disease, NIH,
Pub. No 95–1468–1995: 553–570).
Overall, beneficiaries with diabetes are
hospitalized 1.5 times more often than
beneficiaries without diabetes. HCFA–
3002–F ‘‘Expanded Coverage for
Outpatient Diabetes Self-Management
Training and Diabetes Outcome
Measurements’’, provided for uniform
coverage of diabetes outpatient selfmanagement
training services. These
services include educational and
training services furnished to a
beneficiary with diabetes by an entity
approved to furnish the services. The
physician or qualified non-physician
practitioner treating the beneficiary’s
diabetes would certify that these
services are needed as part of a
comprehensive plan of care. This rule
established the quality standards that an
entity would be required to meet in
order to participate in furnishing
diabetes outpatient self-management
training services. It set forth payment
amounts that have been established in
consultation with appropriate diabetes
organizations. It implements section
4105 of the Balanced Budget Act of
1997. Form Number: CMS–R–247 (OCN:
0938–0818); Frequency: Recordkeeping
and Reporting—Occasionally; Affected
Public: Business or other for-profit
institutions; Number of Respondents:
5327; Total Annual Responses: 63,924;
Total Annual Hours: 197,542. (For
policy questions regarding this
collection contact Kristin Shifflett at
410–786–4133. For all other issues call
410–786–1326.)
4. Type of Information Collection
Request: Extension of a currently
approved collection; Title of
Information Collection: Medicare
Quality of Care Complaint Form; Use: In
accordance with Section 1154(a)(14) of
the Social Security Act, Quality
Improvement Organizations (QIOs) are
required to conduct appropriate reviews
of all written complaints submitted by
beneficiaries concerning the quality of
care received. The Medicare Quality of
Care Complaint Form will be used by
Medicare beneficiaries to submit quality
of care complaints. This form will
establish a standard form for all
beneficiaries to utilize and ensure
pertinent information is obtained by
QIOs to effectively process these
complaints. Form Number: CMS–10287
(OCN: 0938–1102); Frequency:
Reporting—Occasionally; Affected
Public: Individuals or Households;
Number of Respondents: 3,500; Total
Annual Responses: 3,500; Total Annual
Hours: 583. (For policy questions
regarding this collection contact Coles
Mercier at 410–786–2112. For all other
issues call 410–786–1326.)
5. Type of Information Collection
Request: Reinstatement with change of a
currently approved collection; Title of
Information Collection: Conditions of
Participation for Portable X-ray
Suppliers and Supporting Regulations
in 42 CFR Sections 486.104, 486.106,
486.110; Use: The requirements
contained in this information collection
request are classified as conditions of
participation or conditions for coverage.
These conditions are based on a
provision specified in law relating to
diagnostic X-ray tests ‘‘furnished in a
place of residence used as the patient’s
home,’’ and are designed to ensure that
each supplier has a properly trained
staff to provide the appropriate type and
level of care, as well as, a safe physical
environment for patients. CMS uses
these conditions to certify suppliers of
portable X-ray services wishing to
participate in the Medicare program.
This is standard medical practice and is
necessary in order to help to ensure the
well-being, safety and quality
professional medical treatment
accountability for each patient. Form
Number: CMS–R–43 (OCN: 0938–0338);
Frequency: Yearly; Affected Public:
Business or other for-profit and Not-forprofit
institutions; Number of
Respondents: 578; Total Annual
Responses: 578; Total Annual Hours:
948. (For policy questions regarding this
collections contact Alesia Hovatter at
410–786–6861. For all other issues call
410–786–1326.)
VerDate Mar<15>2010 18:05 May 09, 2013 Jkt 229001 PO 00000 Frm 00038 Fmt 4703 Sfmt 4703 E:\FR\FM\10MYN1.SGM 10MYN1 mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with NOTICES
27402 Federal Register / Vol. 78, No. 91 / Friday, May 10, 2013 / Notices
6. Type of Information Collection
Request: New collection (Request for a
new OMB control number); Title of
Information Collection: Annual Report
of Physician-Owned Hospital
Ownership and/or Investment Interest;
Use: Section 6001 of the Affordable Care
Act (ACA) requires Medicare hospitals
to report whether they have any
physician owners including
immediately family members of the
physician.
Currently the CMS 855A captures
basic ownership/managerial information
on providers. The CMS 855A was
revised in July 2011 and a specific
attachment designed to capture
physician-owned hospital ownership
and investment interest data was added
to the form. The attachment is being
removed from the CMS 855A
application because the annual
reporting requirement for physicianowned
hospitals is not required for
Medicare enrollment processing. This
physician-owned hospital data
collection is mandated to be reported on
an annual basis. Additionally, the ACA
prohibits the expansion of current
physician-owned hospitals and banned
the establishment of new ones making
the CMS 855A the improper method to
collect this required annual report.
CMS is requesting the physicianowned
hospital ownership information,
investment information or both,
previously collected in Attachment 1 of
the CMS 855A enrollment application to
become a stand-alone form with a
unique OMB number for the following
reasons:
• The physician-owned data
collection has a small targeted audience
of approximately 140 physician-owned
hospitals nationwide.
• The physician-owned data
collection is required annually, as noted
above.
• The data required under section
6001 is more specific than the data
currently collected on the CMS–855A
provider enrollment application.
• The data is not required for
Medicare provider enrollment purposes.
Form Number: CMS–855 (POH)(OCN:
0938-New); Frequency: Reporting—
Yearly; Affected Public: Private Sector—
Business or other for-profits and not-forprofit
institutions; Number of
Respondents: 140; Total Annual
Responses: 140; Total Annual Hours:
140. (For policy questions regarding this
collection contact Kim McPhillips at
410–786–5374. For all other issues call
410–786–1326.)
7. Type of Information Collection
Request: Revision of a currently
approved collection; Title of
Information Collection: Hospital and
Health Care Complexes and Supporting
Regulations in 42 CFR 413.20 and
413.24; Use: Medicare Part A
institutional providers must provide
adequate cost data to receive Medicare
reimbursement (42 CFR 413.24(a)).
Providers must submit the cost data to
their Medicare Fiscal Intermediary (FI)/
Medicare Administrative Contractor
(MAC) through the Medicare cost report
(MCR). We are submitting a revision of
the Hospital and Hospital Health Care
Complex Cost Report, Form CMS–2552–
10. Form CMS 2552–10 is used by
hospitals participating in the Medicare
program to report the health care costs
to determine the amount of
reimbursable costs for services rendered
to Medicare beneficiaries. The revisions
were caused by legislative requirements
in the Patient Protection and Affordable
Care Act of 2010 and the Temporary
Payroll Tax Cut Continuation Act of
2011. Form Number: CMS–2552–10
(OCN: 0938–0050); Frequency:
Reporting—Yearly; Affected Public:
Private Sector—Business or other forprofits
and not-for-profit institutions;
Number of Respondents: 6,171; Total
Annual Responses: 6,171; Total Annual
Hours: 4,153,083. (For policy questions
regarding this collection contact Nadia
Massuda at 410–786–5834. For all other
issues call 410–786–1326.)
8. Type of Information Collection
Request: Reinstatement with change of a
previously approved collection. Title of
Information Collection: Collection of
Diagnostic Data from Medicare
Advantage Organizations for Risk
Adjusted Payments. Use: CMS will use
the data to make risk adjusted payment
under Parts C. MA and MA–PD plans
will use the data to develop their Parts
C bids. As required by law, CMS also
annually publishes the risk adjustment
factors for plans and other interested
entities in the Advance Notice of
Methodological Changes for MA
Payment Rates (every February) and the
Announcement of Medicare Advantage
Payment Rates (every April). Lastly,
CMS issues monthly reports to each
individual plan that contains the CMS–
HCC and RxHCC models’ output and the
risk scores and reimbursements for each
beneficiary that is enrolled in their plan.
Form Number: CMS–10062 (OMB 0938–
0838). Frequency: Quarterly. Affected
Public: Private Sector (business or other
for-profit and not-for-profit institutions).
Number of Respondents: 766. Total
Annual Responses: 830,000. Total
Annual Hours: 40,650. (For policy
questions regarding this collection
contact Michael Massimini at 410–786–
1566. For all other issues call 410–786–
1326.)
To obtain copies of the supporting
statement and any related forms for the
proposed paperwork collections
referenced above, access CMS’ Web site
address at http://www.cms.hhs.gov/
PaperworkReductionActof1995, or
Email your request, including your
address, phone number, OMB number,
and CMS document identifier, to
Paperwork@cms.hhs.gov, or call the
Reports Clearance Office on (410) 786–
1326.
In commenting on the proposed
information collections please reference
the document identifier or OMB control
number. To be assured consideration,
comments and recommendations must
be submitted in one of the following
ways by July 9, 2013:
1. Electronically. You may submit
your comments electronically to http://
www.regulations.gov. Follow the
instructions for ‘‘Comment or
Submission’’ or ‘‘More Search Options’’
to find the information collection
document(s) accepting comments.
2. By regular mail. You may mail
written comments to the following
address: CMS, Office of Strategic
Operations and Regulatory Affairs,
Division of Regulations Development,
Attention: Document Identifier/OMB
Control Number lll, Room C4–26–
05, 7500 Security Boulevard, Baltimore,
Maryland 21244–1850.
Dated: May 6, 2013.
Martique Jones,
Deputy Director, Regulations Development
Group, Office of Strategic Operations and
Regulatory Affairs.
[FR Doc. 2013–11035 Filed 5–9–13; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4120–01–P

Canadian Healthcare Innovation, the MyMedRec App Goes Global





















OTTAWA, ONTARIO -- (Marketwired) -- 05/14/13 --MyMedRec, one of Canada's top free iPhone apps to help people and their families keep track of medication use and immunization history, is now available internationally. MyMedRec
allows users to keep information on their medications and vaccines at their fingertips, ready to share with their healthcare providers.
The personal electronic medication record empowers the growing number of smartphone owners who use mobile devices to manage a wide range of personal data, including their medication information. The World Health Organization has established safe medication use as a priority given that an estimated 50 per cent of patients do not take their medication correctly, while studies have shown that proper adherence to medication improve health outcomes.
Earlier this year, MyMedRec reached the top ten list for free iPhone and iPad apps and has been downloaded by more than 8,000 Canadians. Until now, it was only available in Canada. Consumer requests for the app have come from the U.S, Ireland, Saudi Arabia, and other countries. MyMedRechas received praise from users, health care professionals and app reviewers alike.
"This is a great, innovative app! You are able to keep important medical information with you, ready for use when needed. I especially like the feature where the user is able to photograph and include the label as part of the database for both prescription and natural medications," added Kathleen, who uses the app.
"MyMedRec is a clear, simple and easy to use mobile app. It's a great tool to help people keep a list of not only their prescriptions, but also their vitamins, non-prescription drugs, supplements and immunizations," Kelly Grindrod, Assistant Professor, School of Pharmacy, University of Waterloo and mobile health technology researcher.
MyMedRec was launched in Canada by seven of the country's leading health care organizations to promote adherence and the safe and responsible use of medications and vaccines. Features include a reminder to take a dose or to refill a prescription. MyMedRec is the latest innovation in the "Knowledge is the best medicine" program which was developed in 1994 by Canada's Research-Based Pharmaceutical Companies (Rx&D) as a tool to help Canadians take control of their health and work with their healthcare team to manage medicines safely and appropriately.
"We have been working with our partners to make these tools available because we know that proper adherence to medication leads to healthier outcomes for patients," said Russell Williams, President of Canada's Research-Based Pharmaceutical Companies. "Based on the reaction we have had in Canada and the requests we have received from around the world to make it available globally, we are thrilled to share this tool that we believe everyone can benefit from."
Key Features:
--  Medication and natural products dose reminders 
--  A record of when medicines were taken 
--  A separate archive for medicines the user is no longer taking 
--  Multiple profiles allows the user to keep track of family's health
    information 
--  Easily adds entries to the device's calendar for prescription refills,
    medical appointments and upcoming immunization 
--  Emails parts or all of the user's profile and medication to a healthcare
    provider, as necessary 
--  Additional security with optional separate password and data encryption
    upon locking the device 

The app was developed with the support and collaboration of leading health organizations, including Canada's Research Based Pharmaceutical Companies, Institute for Safe Medication Practices Canada, Canadian Medical Association, Canadian Nurses Association, Canadian Pharmacists Association, Victorian Order of Nurses and Best Medicines Coalition.

From god to guide: can patient-centred care become a reality in the NHS?



Most parts of the NHS are only paying lip service to patient engagement, recently hailed as the 'next blockbuster drug'
Patient engagement is hailed as the 'next blockbuster drug'
Educating patients so that they can make informed choices is vital. Photograph: Suzanne Plunkett/Reuters
As healthcare systems the world over continue to groan under the weight of rising expectations, ageing populations and squeezed finances, the search for viable long-term solutions shows no sign of slowing.
For many, the focus remains on system reform – finding new ways to make the money go further by redesigning services to be more efficient. But, increasingly, attention is turning to the people who use healthcare services as the potential saviour of them.
As Maureen Bisognano, president of the influential US-based Institute for Health Improvement, told the International Forum on Quality and Safety in Health in London in April: "Patient engagement is the next blockbuster drug."
Patient engagement is certainly not a new concept but, in truth, most parts of the NHS are still only paying lip service to it. The default position for many health professionals is still to think in terms of, "What's the matter with you?" rather than, "What matters to you?"
It's easy to see why. Most systems, our own included, are heavily geared towards the five hours a year that, on average, we each consume healthcare. However, ccording to a new report by KPMG, called Something to Teach, Something to Learn: Global perspectives on healthcare, the real gains are being made by health systems that understand the importance of the 8,760 hours a year when we are not officially classed as patients.
Technological advances, such as smartphone apps which can speed a patient's hospital discharge by allowing them to measure ECGs at home, or telemedicine systems, which deliver multidisciplinary virtual clinics, offer a partial solution to empowering patients.
But the reason these breakthroughs have not revolutionised care in the way we thought they might 10 years ago is that a more fundamental issue is being missed – that of understanding a patient's needs beyond treating the condition with which they have been diagnosed. Too often, our systems encourage the health professional to treat the illness, not the person. We chase narrow biomedical indicators, which, while important, don't capture all that matters to the patient.
There's now a great deal of evidence which shows that when patients are asked what they really want, they often choose a different (and in many cases less expensive) course of action to the one their doctor or nurse might have recommended. For example, most patients do not want to spend their last hours in hospital, yet the majority do.
Educating patients so that they can make informed choices, not just about their care but about their overall lifestyles, is vital. But it is also only half the battle. The key is listening to, and acting on, those choices – only then do patients become truly empowered.
And that's where system change comes in. The emerging evidence from around the world, as highlighted in Something to Teach, Something to Learn, is that to thrive in the challenging years ahead, healthcare systems will need to reorient themselves around the needs of patients.
Hospitals will have to look beyond their four walls, bridging the gap with primary care and transforming to become part of health systems, taking responsibility for entire pathways of care.
Primary care will need to become more accessible and more time will need to be given to understanding the needs and expectations of the 3% of patients that drive 50% of NHS costs every year.
These patients, often with multiple conditions, need continuity and access to integrated services which combine primary care, supported by specialists and the effective use of telephone and web-based tools and support. For this to work, health system funding also needs to be reshaped. There are already signs, from around the world, that payers – be they private insurers or governments – are becoming more active.
They are gaining a better understanding of what constitutes quality in the eyes of patients and designing new types of contracts that reward "value" rather than "volume".
ParkinsonNet, a ground-breaking patient-led education programme in the Netherlands, is a great example. It has shifted perceptions about what constitutes value for Parkinson's patients and, as a result, has radically changed practitioner behaviour. The programme has already halved the number of hip fractures suffered by this patient group and delivered savings of £13m.
In a system designed around the patient, clinicians need to move from god to guide, focusing their skills on the provision of information and support to help patients make effective choices and manage their own health and wellbeing.
True patient empowerment is not a bolt-on; it should be the centrepiece of the healthcare jigsaw.
This partnership is pivotal and central to an NHS which delivers both high quality healthcare and value too. Is it possible? With our greatest asset – the hundreds of thousands of front-line NHS staff who work with patients every day – yes, absolutely.
Mark Britnell is chairman of KPMG's global healthcare practice.
This article is published by Guardian Professional.

Responsible Solutions That Protect and Preserve Medicare



Posted on 05/13/2013 by   

This is a guest post by Sean Voskuhl – State Director, AARP Oklahoma
Growing up in rural Oklahoma, I saw first-hand the importance of Medicare.  Finding accessible and affordable health care was always very difficult.  Many folks had no choice but to purchase a catastrophic/high deductible plan, or they relied on a spouse to get coverage by taking a job in town, or they went without health insurance at all. Simply put, most people gambled and prayed, trying to hold on till they could get on Medicare.
Today, Medicare is the primary health insurance program for the 49 million Americans who are 65 and older.  Roughly, one in four of those beneficiaries are rural residents, and that number will only rise in coming years.  With changing demographics and rising health care costs, Medicare is facing a number of challenges.  Unfortunately, some in Washington believe the only way to address those challenges is to cut Medicare benefits or force seniors to pay more.  No doubt any such changes to Medicare will greatly impact rural America.
Is there a better way?  What about cracking down on waste, fraud and abuse?  The U.S. health system wastes as much as a third of all spending because of inefficient payment systems, uncoordinated care, duplication, over-testing and unnecessary paperwork.  It’s estimated that Medicare could save hundreds of billions of dollars just by reducing waste.  More could be saved by stepping up fraud detection.  In 2011 alone, anti-fraud efforts recovered $4.1 billion.  In October 2012, Medicare Strike Force operations in seven cities led to charges against 91 individuals-including doctors, nurses and other licensed medical professionals-for their alleged participation in Medicare fraud schemes involving some $432 million in false billing.  And yet we know much more can and should be done.
Here are some other examples of Medicare fraud that may hit closer to home: a healthcare provider bills Medicare for services you never received; a supplier bills Medicare for equipment you never got; someone uses your Medicare card to get medical care, supplies, or equipment; a company offers a Medicare drug plan that has not been approved by Medicare; or, a company uses false information to mislead you into joining a Medicare plan.
If we want to preserve and protect Medicare for future generations, it’s essential to crack down on fraud and abuse.  The resulting savings will cut costs for families, businesses and the federal government, and increase the quality of services for those who need care. But stopping fraud requires the cooperation of everyone-the federal government, state governments, health care providers, insurers, law enforcement, and even people like you and me.
To learn more about the challenges facing Medicare, and hear what you can do to help stop Medicare fraud, tune in to AARP Live on RFD-TV this Thursday, May 16th at 9p.m. CT on RFD-TV. I’ll be joined by AARP state director Greg Marchildon (VT), AARP senior advisor Pete Jeffries, and AARP Iowa volunteer Maryalice Larson, all of whom have a first-hand view of the challenges facing Medicare. Let’s find responsible solutions that will keep Medicare strong without shifting the burden of higher health care costs onto seniors and future retirees.
Tune in to AARP Live on RFD on Thursday, May 16th at 9 pm CST to learn more.
Please join me this Thursday night for AARP Live! on RFD-TV, or watch it streaming live at www.aarp.org/rfdand on Facebook
(click here  for “by zipcode” channel locator) Viewers are encouraged to phone in during the show, 888- 687-2277 toll-free, to share your questions/concerns.

Managed Medicare Advantage Plans Demonstrate Better Outcomes for Patients



By Analyzing Insurance Claims From 3 Million U.S. Medicare Patients, The Boston Consulting Group Finds That Managed Private Plans Outperform Traditional Fee-for-Service Medicine on Health Care Quality and Value
BOSTON, MA--(Marketwired - May 14, 2013) - As health systems around the world experiment with alternative models for care delivery and reimbursement to improve health care quality and lower cost, they can learn a lot from the care-delivery models used by private payers in U.S. Medicare Advantage plans, according to a new study by The Boston Consulting Group (BCG).
After analyzing claims data for 3 million Medicare patients, BCG found that on three internationally accepted dimensions of health care quality -- single-year mortality, recovery from acute episodes of care requiring hospitalization, and the sustainability of health over time -- patients enrolled in Medicare Advantage plans offered by private insurers had considerably better outcomes than those participating in Medicare on a traditional fee-for-service basis. The improved quality is delivered on top of the well-understood point that these models already deliver lower costs.
"Our findings demonstrate that the more managed plans do not compromise quality. Just the opposite: they deliver higher-quality care at a lower cost than fee-for-service medicine and thus do a better job of improving health care value," said Jon Kaplan, a BCG partner and lead author of the study. "Payers, providers, and policymakers have a lot to gain by more broadly aligning incentives and delivering strong care management, similar to that utilized by the Medicare Advantage plans."
The findings are detailed in a new report titled Alternative Payer Models Show Improved Health-Care Value, released today on www.bcgperspectives.com.
The majority of the U.S. Medicare-eligible population receive care from doctors and other providers on a traditional fee-for-service basis, with the costs of the services reimbursed directly by Medicare. About one-quarter are enrolled in Medicare Advantage health plans provided by private insurers.
What distinguishes Medicare Advantage plans from traditional fee-for-service plans is the degree to which they use mechanisms designed to encourage the delivery of cost-effective quality care. Three critical mechanisms are financial incentives that are aligned with clinical best practices, a selective network of providers, and more active care management that emphasizes prevention to minimize expensive acute care.
Of the 3 million patients for which BCG analyzed data, approximately 1.3 million used providers on a traditional fee-for-service basis. The remainder were enrolled in one of three types of private Medicare Advantage plans: a preferred provider organization (PPO), a health maintenance organization (HMO), or an HMO with global capitation.
Among the study's specific findings:
   -- Single-year mortality rates fell from 6.8 percent in the traditional fee-for-service sample to 1.8 percent in the three progressively managed delivery models. The lowest rates and the greatest performance were seen in the HMO plans with global capitation. Patients in the three managed models achieved these lower levels of single-year mortality quickly, within the first year of enrollment. 
 
   -- Patients in the Medicare Advantage plans had shorter average stays in the hospital. Compared to the fee-for-service sample, the capitated HMO sample had stays that were, on average about 19 percent shorter. 
 
   -- Patients in the managed plans were more likely to receive preventive care and less likely to suffer from disease-specific complications. For example, diabetic patients in the fee-for-service sample had an average of 11.5 amputations per 1,000 patients; those in HMO plans with global capitation had only 0.3. 

"We've found that U.S. private insurers have created an operating model that can deliver better care at a lower cost and have a major role to play in the ongoing national efforts to improve health care quality," said Stefan Larsson, a BCG senior partner and coauthor of the report. "Quite simply, we've found that the more aligned the care, the better the quality delivered."

Best Opportunities & Biggest Threats in Healthcare


Best Opportunities & Biggest Threats in Healthcare


At the Becker's Hospital Review Annual Meeting in Chicago on May 10, a panel of health system executives discussed the greatest opportunities and biggest threats ahead for the healthcare industry. 

Barry Arbuckle, PhD, president and CEO of MemorialCare Health System based in Fountain Valley, Calif.; Daniel Slipkovich, CEO of Franklin, Tenn.-based Capella Healthcare; Sandra Bruce, president and CFO of Chicago-based Presence Health; and Stephen Bonner, president and CEO of Cancer Treatment Centers of America based in Schaumburg, Ill., sat on the panel, moderated by Fox News anchor and former White House correspondent Bret Baier.

Here is an edited transcript of the panelists' discussion:

Bret Baier: What opportunities do you see in the healthcare industry as we move into the first year of health reform?

Stephen Bonner: We need to bring more intelligence into healthcare. We're now moving into a phase of consumers, regardless of what might be set by federal policy, becoming more engaged in their healthcare with more health savings and savvier in how they buy their care. The health reform law and the exchanges are rapidly accelerating that whole structure. It's an unintended consequence, but we're going to end up with more engaged consumers. If we listen, they'll help us deliver cheaper and better care without needing to funnel money through the feds. There's a lot left to be determined, but we think [the U.S. healthcare system] is really missing a major opportunity. We have this incredible capability and capacity, but there's a disconnect between desire and what's available,  and that's not a U.S. phenomenon. Why shouldn't we flip it around and use our excess capacity and invite people to come to the U.S. and improve on that?

Sandy Bruce: Only God knows. We're the largest Medicaid provider in the state, and the exchanges are a big worry for us.  Lots of people will get coverage, but then what happens when they come into our doors without realizing they'll still owe 30 percent of the bill? That'll create a financial burden on providers, if we're not careful. Most of us have grown up building hospitals and filling beds, but that's clearly changed. I think the real opportunities for healthcare lie in the changing revenue streams in different care settings and for different metrics of care. I think we also have a huge opportunity to reduce variation in healthcare. Within my own system of 12 hospitals, we think we could save between 20 and 40 percent by reducing clinical variations among our physicians. [Electronic health records], although they're expensive, can help us achieve that. Another piece I'm particularly concerned about is that a quarter of Americans could be covered by Medicaid in a year. We are oblgated to figure out a way to deliver care to them at a very different cost structure. It can't look like what we've been doing.

Barry Arbuckle, PhD: The upcoming changes are mindboggling in significance. I'm a big fan of complete connectivity and seamless connection to population health. You're fooling yourself if you think you can do population health or keep physicians integrated without it. There are also lots of interesting and creative partnerships being formed between providers that provide benefits of scale but fall short of a full transaction.

Dan Slipkovich: We're repeating a lot of what we did in the 1990s. We're expanding outside our walls and buying other entities, etc., but I'd tell you it's going to stick this time. In the '90s, we simply didn't have the technology to follow through on the initiatives of the time. The trouble for us now is going to be meeting the influx of new patients, many of whom will be covered by Medicaid. Many say hospitals will benefit from more insured patients, but it's going to be a shift to re-spending the same dollar amount on a much broader population. Access is also a big issue. Our emergency department services grew 10 percent last year, but that's because so many patients didn't have anywhere else to go.

Mr. Baier: What looming threats have been keeping you up at night?

Dr. Arbuckle: There are solvency concerns about the Medicaid program, as well as Medicare so long as politicians keep using it as their piggy bank to solve other budget problems. The solution, I believe, is in managed care. It's the only thing that can cause those programs to survive, but it takes infrastructure and experience. Everything is harkening back to the '90s, but I truly believe we're doing it different this time. We have better systems, better technology, even better intentions. Before it was all about money, but now it's survival. We have better regulation now, too. We might actually be successful this time.

Mr. Bonner: The biggest threat is misleading for what we're trying to create and what it'll take to create it. Healthcare has become so politicized, but can we really engage people in the discussions about how to do healthcare better? I think we're failing to engage in the right conversations. We need to connect the will to drive quality to where it belongs and cost what it ought to cost. There's a lack of will to tackle really tough systemic issues, such as primary care. Can we tackle malpractice in this country? Can we tackle transparency? We equip people with the kind of information that JD Power & Associates give to keep them from buying crummy products, but not in healthcare. How do we pretend to be a consumer-driven industry if we can't do that? The greatest clinical opportunities are through innovations in oncology, finding the best balance between safety, efficacy and speed.The cost we can take out of the system and the human cost we can take out in avoiding side effects is astounding.

Ms. Bruce: We believe there's probably overcapacity in hospitals today, and acute care will shrink. Everything's moving into medical home office ambulatory settings. What will become of the capital investments we've all made in patient towers and all the rest over the years. We're struggling on where to place the bets on where the industry is going. We're also starting to worry that our biggest competitor is no longer other large hospital systems but Walgreens and the retail clinics. We're still protecting our big-box assets, while others are coming in who'll get into the new industry better.

Mr. Baier:
 What do you predict other systems will begin doing to adapt to the changing landscape of healthcare?

Dr. Arbuckle: 
I have a hard time predicting what's going to happen. There will be changes in resource utilization without a doubt. At the same time, there's a burgeoning population of seniors who will utilize healthcare resources at six times that of the commercial population. We've also got  an obesity epidemic in this country and all the problems that causes. I believe we'll see fewer beds in larger markets as we shift to more population health management in the ambulatory setting. Freestanding, non-profit hospitals historically have had an amazing ability to lose money and hang on for years, and this time, I worry they may not. Now is the time to be exploring partnerships and transaction opportunities of all kinds, not when you're desperate. There's a major problem with staffing resources as well. I have hundreds of open positions that I can't fill, even in this unemployment market. Right now we've got excess capacity in the marketplace, consolidation will drive that excess out. I firmly believe over the next five to eight years, you'll see 500 fewer hospitals in this country. 

Ms. Bruce: The framework of our competition is changing. Consumers are changing rapidly too. If we connect with them, learn what they value and how to deliver that to them, we'll still fill our patient towers, but we don't need to make people come to the big boxes to get their height and weight. There's no need for them to come in if their iPhone can send a high-resolution image of their lesion to a physician who can diagnose and prescribe care remotely. Customers know that, so how can we engage them, and will we get paid to deliver that way? One of my doctors has been doing just that, but hasn't told people about it because he knew it wouldn't produce any RVUs. Johns Hopkins is piloting a stay-home admission model, which is cheaper and minimizes infection risk, but it still has to be approved by payors.

Dr. Arbuckle: I think we'll see a resurrection of worksite clinics, but the only way it can work economically is if there are aligned incentives. We know there is a lot of waste in the healthcare system. I recently learned I have an allergy to beestings. I now get allergy shots twice each week. For those who'd have to leave work to travel to a physician's clinic, wait to be seen, handle the billing and return, that's two hours of work time lost, and twice  per week. The productivity loss is crazy for employers! That's a perfect candidate for a worksite clinic. Obviously we've got a lot of changes and challenges, and for us it starts with people. Everyone should engage their boards and physicians to get the people side  of this right. Beyond that, it's easy to get caught up in the problem of the day. Despite what happens with Medicaid, we know what we have to do — stay very focused.

Mr. Bonner: The fundamental here is to stay clear on our fundamental purpose and who we need to serve. Healthcare is rightfully under the spotlight. The wisdom of the customer coupled with the wisdom of medicine and employers brings us all to a more efficient, more effective delivery of care. We know waiting in hospitals builds stress, wastes time for us and for employers, so last year we took 150,000 hours of patient wait time out of our process. Listen to customers. There's a great future in healthcare in America. A lot of [healthcare executives] have one foot on the dock and one foot in the boat. Call your shots, be courageous and increase your appetite for risk.